Monday, March 05, 2007

The Art of Seduction

No one can fall in love if he is even partially satisfied with what he is or who he is. The experience of falling in love originates in an extreme depression, an inability to find something that has value in everyday life. The “symptom” of the predisposition to fall in love is not the conscious desire to do so, the intense desire to enrich our lives; it is the profound sense of being worthless and of having nothing that is valuable and the shame of not having it …. For this reason, falling in love occurs more frequently among young people, since they are most profoundly uncertain, unsure of their worth, and often ashamed of themselves. The same thing applies to people of other ages when they lose something in their lives – when their youth ends or when they start to grow old.
– Francesco Alberoni, Falling in Love, translated by Lawrence Venuti.

“What can Love be then?” I said. “A mortal?”
“As in my previous examples, he is half-way between mortal and immortal.”
“What sort of being is he then, Diotima?”
“He is a great spirit, Socrates; everything that is of nature of a spirit is half-god and half-man.”
“Who are his parents?” I asked
“That is a rather long story,” she answered, “but I will tell you. On the day Aphrodite was born, the gods were feasting, among them Contrivance, the son of Invention; and after dinner, seeing that a party was in progress, Poverty came to beg and stood at the door. Now Contrivance was drunk with nectar – wine, I may say, had not yet been discovered – and went out into the garden of Zeus, and was overcome by sleep. So, Poverty, thinking to alleviate her wretched condition by bearing a child to Contrivance, lay with him and conceived Love. Since Love was begotten on Aphrodite’s birthday, and since he has also an innate passion for the beautiful, and so for the beauty of Aphrodite herself, he became her follower and servant. Again, having Contrivance for his father and Poverty for her mother, he bears the following character. He is always poor, and, far from being sensitive and beautiful, as most people imagine, he is hard and weather-beaten, shoeless and homeless, always sleeping out for want of bed, on the ground, on the door-steps, and in the street. So far he takes from her mother and lives in want. But, being also his father’s son, he schemes to get for himself whatever is beautiful and good; he is bold and forward and strenuous, always devising tricks like a cunning huntsman.”
- Plato, Symposium, translated by Walter Hamilton

We are all like pieces of the coins that children break in half for keepsakes – making two out of one, like the flatfish – and each of us is forever seeking that half that will tally with himself …. And so all this to-do is a relic of that original state of ours when we were whole, and now, when we are longing for and following after that primeval wholeness, we say, we are in love.
- Aristophanes’s speech in Plato’s Symposium, quoted in James Mandrell, Don Juan and the Point of Honor

The normal rhythm of life oscillates in general between a mild satisfaction with oneself and a slight discomfort, originating in the knowledge of one’s personal shortcomings. We should like to be as handsome, young, strong or clever as other people of our acquaintance. We wish we could achieve as much as they do, long for similar advantages, positions, the same of greater success. To be delighted with oneself is the exception and, often enough, a smoke screen which we produce for ourselves, and of course for others. Somewhere in it is a lingering feeling of discomfort with ourselves and a slight self-dislike. I assert that an increase of the spirit of discontent renders a person especially susceptible to “falling in love” … In most cases this attitude of disquiet is unconscious, but in some it reaches the threshold of awareness in the form of a slight uneasiness, it a stagnant dissatisfaction, or a realization of being upset without knowing why.
- Theodor Reik, Of Love and Lust